Welcome to Fully Baked, our Sunday newsletter where we validate one our previous ideas as often as SpaceX does something completely insane 🚀
In today's edition:
🌙 The sleep-pouch idea we're revisiting
🔬 What our fake-door test revealed
🚀 Who we'd speak to before spending more
🤑 Why an email signup isn't customer CAC
⚔️ What does the competitive landscape look like?
❓ Is this idea a go or a no-go?
Let's get into it.


🌙 Sleep Pouches
Pouch potato
👤 Source: We shared this in edition #530. This time, we built a brand and ran an ad to see who'd bite.
❌ Problem:
Plenty of us lie awake with our brains refusing to switch off. In a CDC survey published this year, 15.4% of US adults said they had trouble falling asleep most days or every day, and 18.1% struggled to stay asleep.
The usual fixes aren't always reliable. Researchers tested 25 melatonin gummy products and found 22 didn't match their label. One contained 347% of the advertised dose. There's an opening for something people can trust.
✅ Solution:
Launch Lull, a nicotine-free sleep pouch you tuck under your top lip about 20 minutes before bed.
Each one has a small dose of melatonin (0.3mg) alongside L-theanine, magnesium and apigenin, a compound found in chamomile. No sugar, no water, and it's designed to help you wind down rather than knock you out.
Sell it direct as a monthly subscription, in a tin that lives on your bedside table.
🧑💻 Prototyping: Demo

🧩 Build A CRM Around Your Business
At the start, your sales process fits in a spreadsheet. Then the team grows, the follow-ups multiply, and the spreadsheet starts behaving like a full-time employee with no handover notes.
Attio is the CRM for agentic revenue. Build it around your business and run revenue plays from founder-led sales to your first team of AEs.
The Attio Startup Program offers 80% off the annual Pro plan for your first year and 30% off your second. You also get dedicated onboarding support and perks from Linear, Notion, Intercom and more.
Your company is changing. Your CRM should be able to come with it.

🔬 Our Validation Process
🖥️ Desktop Research
The pouch habit is enormous. PMI reported shipping over 200 million cans of Zyn in the U.S. in Q1 2025, up 53% year on year. Millions of people are already used to putting something under their lip, which makes a sleep pouch a much easier sell than it would have been five years ago.
More people are reaching for melatonin. Use among US adults went from 0.4% to 2.1% between 1999 and 2018, according to an NIH-funded study. The trouble is, melatonin itself is cheap. One January deal offered 200 tablets for about $6.30, about 3¢ each. That's a promotional benchmark, not a current everyday price. Whatever we charge, we're selling the format and the brand, not the ingredient.
📣 The Fake Door Test
We built an AI landing page with a product shot, ingredients, a price and a "Join the waitlist" button, then ran Facebook ads to US audiences using AI-generated images. No physical product, photoshoot or designer.
The result: about $54 spent. One email signup.
That's an expensive email address, and little reason to scale this version. But without impressions, page visits and conversion rates, we can't tell whether the problem was the ad, the page or the offer.
It's a weak signal from one small test, not proof that nobody wants sleep pouches.

🚀 Acquiring Customers
Given the result, these are channels we'd test if we revisited the idea.
👥 Early Customers
Borrow a small, relevant audience. Partner with a few creators who talk about shift work or evening routines. Give each a dedicated landing page so you can see whose audience actually signs up.
Recruit a founding customer group. Offer the first 25 people early access in exchange for feedback. Show the proposed price upfront, then ask for a refundable reservation once the product and launch timeline are credible.
📈 Scaling Acquisition
Test creator-led wind-down videos on TikTok Shop, where other similar brands are excelling.
If repeat orders work, explore pharmacies and airport travel stores as retail channels.

🤑 The Economics of This Business
🏷️ Pricing
We'd test prices below the original $39:
Single tin: $15 for 15 pouches. About $1 each.
Four-tin bundle: $45 for 60 pouches. 75¢ each. At one nightly, that's roughly two months' supply, so we'd test an eight-week reorder cadence.
These are proposed prices, not validated willingness to pay.
🧮 Unit Economics
Four-tin order: $45 revenue less $10 manufacturing, $5.50 shipping, $1 packing and $1.60 fees leaves about $27, or 60%.
Single-tin order: $15 less $2.50 manufacturing, $4.50 shipping, $1 packing and 75¢ fees leaves $6.25, or 42%.
The deciding number is customer CAC. With about $27 contribution per bundle, we'd need CAC below $27 for first-order payback.
Repeat orders could improve the picture, but we'd need to see customers reorder after roughly eight weeks before counting on them.

⚔️ The Competitive Landscape
🏷️ Primary Competitors
Ultra (about $1.07 a pouch, 69¢ on subscription): The closest thing to Lull already on the market, with 1mg of melatonin plus L-theanine, lemon balm and chamomile. It's built its audience on TikTok Shop, which is exactly where we'd want to sell.
Deepkold (under 50¢ a pouch): A cheaper sleep pouch with melatonin, L-theanine and magnesium, sold in bulk sleeves. It sets the bottom of the market, and it's well below where we'd want to price.
Melatonin gummies and tablets (about 3¢ a dose): The real market leader. Cheap, on every pharmacy shelf and already in millions of bedside drawers. You'd beat them on convenience and trust, but never on price.
🎯 The Gap
Nobody has built a sleep pouch brand people actually love yet. The products that exist are either sold like supplements or like budget nicotine alternatives. There's room for a calm, premium brand that feels more like a bedtime ritual. The catch is that the formula is easy to copy, so the brand would have to do all the work.

❌ No-Go
We'd give this a No-Go in its current form. Our fake-door test results didn’t blow us away.
The test doesn't rule out the category, but existing competitors mean the pouch format alone isn't a gap. A calmer brand still needs customers willing to choose it and pay.
If we revisit it, we'd pick one audience, confirm the product and claims with qualified specialists, and test willingness to pay.
Until then, we're sleeping on this one.
👋 That's All Folks
We hope you enjoyed today’s edition, shoot us a reply if you have any feedback. We read every single one!
Before you go:
Looking to sponsor Half Baked? Just fill out this form and we’ll get back to you asap.
We recently launched the Half Baked Podcast. If you like this newsletter, you’ll love the podcast. Check it out!
See you soon,




